Award Winners
Alice Fay Di Castagnola Award - 2014
Timothy Donnelly
Finalists
Shane Book
Katy Lederer
Dana Levin
Traveler
Admittedly, there have been times, as after antihistamines
and a lager at the aiprort bar, when I can make like
I belong here, minding my own carry-on behind me
like the nonchalant, bouyed through a mount in cheer
or cheerfulness I can't call false, or can but just plain
don't, my fixity dissolving like some paper boat on blue
carpet scrolling down the gate and aisle, shoulders brushed to
others' gently, neighbor-like, and often, and as if I
hadn't noticed, but I do—it is my task. A sudden flash of
what might happen when it did, but days ago, and then
the rope of calm around my neck again, I settle in my seat,
a window in the back, and pray to what I pay for,
which is an empty sky, or else a cloud in what appears to be
the center of the sky, to feel the fade of what I only
recently eased into, this lack of history between us
making it all the easier. (I think I hadn't expected life
to be kind to me, not in light of the pounding of it, so I must have
thought I could trick it, lead it into thinking I wasn't
really there. Later on, I think I changed my mind, but by
then it was too late.)
Gone forward, pulling it off
but awkwardly, timed as if time's artichoke had wept
in front of me in the white kitchen, or on a pond on which
intoned a lotus, then a moon; greased in plenitude, up to
and including—then all its little hands, which knit
their lifework out of hours, days; centuries unstuck like yellow
vinyl from the tabletop, the noise of it so common-
place we didn't notice it, or when we did, we let it pass
by tactitly as nails until all the landscapes they held up
were taken into custody—and now it can't be heard again.
Or say the flatness of the tabletop were the known
universe, all of it, and I'm just a random smirch residing
in the northeast corner, comparable to the other smirches,
nothing special, until I vanish from this flatness into another
layer of it, into depth. We might think of it as traveling
under the table, but the smirches, who only experience
flatness, know no under. They only know that I was there
and then I wasn't. And when I resurface in an instant
somewhere in the south, it's still just an instant to me,
but to them, who are nowhere to be found, it was an instant
three hundred years in the past.
White birches lean
through a mist like plastic drinking straws, the same
kind a tribesman from Papua New Guinea once drove
through the hole in his septum in lieu of the traditional
wooden spoke or bone. The anthropologist in the back of
the room cried. She had seen the documentary many times before
but still cried. She sensed in this image the collapse
of a culture, its unstoppable tumbling into the corporate
fastfood abyss. I could see this. At the same time I couldn't
look up into his face and make myself see anything less
or more than a person, one with the capacity to choose
or choose not to do what he had done. I knew I had to
be wrong. I knew I should want him not to chose what
he possibly only appeared to have chosen, meaning external
forces might have compelled him to take up the straw
instead of conventional materials, but I couldn't distinguish
between wanting this and wanting to preserve him
in time like an object, even if to do so meant denying him
his ability to choose, permitting him only to do to his face
what left Baltimore comfortable.
Anyone moves through
days less than completely, the washing of dishes
start to finish, water half-scalding the hands so the feet
don't remember events that the land underneath
them supported, a hope for gain so consistent in the humus
it becomes for us an unavoidable drink, the whole
crow family chuffing overhead as we trust our taproots
to skirt the bad aquifer. Anyone oftener in the soft-
scented borders abuzz beside museum doors will anchor
thoughts elsewhere than in insects on whose loud labor
we depend unendingly. As for me, I like to think of myself as able
to function at a certain level, equipped to walk among
a company of bees at ease with my place in an ancient
relation, a live participant in a pattern whose longevity
is a thing of beauty, admiring our symbiosis in Sunday
sun as an abstract love with benefits, but then I think
we'd cloud them in a stink of toxins if they didn't pollinate
the fruit we ate or vomit honey, and they don't think
of us at all, they're too busy, or aren't equipped to, or don't
see the point, if there is any.
Half-aware in the dark
air above New York, a common swift, known to doze in flight
the way a dolphin does through the sea, one hemi-
sphere of its brain set to slow-wave sleep while the other
maintains vigilance, the inner eye of us widening
as it beams back and forth godlike across the soft office
floor of our experience, the outer and inner divisions of it
parted by a cleft that looks from this height like nothing
but a papercut, I drop in on red activity filed in the fourth
quadrant outer division, labyrinth of mismanagement
as far as the eye can see, its index cards alone the size
of antlers on Irish elk, which is to say so large they prevent
successful completion of "the normal business of life,"
I've heard it said, or else it was just some idea I had
once about futility in a bathtub, but when I reach out
to grab the file, having been lowered down to the air-
space just above it, the antiquated suspension system up
and reverses, hauling me backward through the element
I belong to, torn as if from the hand that would spare me
the burden of remembering.
Nothing to be afraid of but
nothing now, a light-absorbing liquid tucked behind
a dam constantly wanting to unknit itself, thinking to fail by plan
might be better than to succeed for a stretch through
violent worry, only to fail in time anyway, you sat beside me
on the green chair, birdlike, fidgeting in your girlhood
as we read together from a magazine, facts about the lives
of honeybees, nothing to be afraid of: to generate,
on average, a single pound of honey, a colony has to draw
nectar from two million flowers, or enough red roses
to send a dozen red roses to every resident of Columbia, MO.
And to visit all those flowers, the colony has to fly,
collectively, fifty thousand miles, over one fifth the distance
from the earth to the moon, which holds our thoughts
in place if we have nowhere else to place them, as when
we read the average worker bee, in all its lifetime, will only
produce one twelfth a teaspoon of honey, meaning that I
have stirred the lifework of a dozen bees into my teacup
thoughtlessly, a devourer of lifeworks, this present only
one example, I turn my head away.
Awake again
in underbrush, scrub pine and sassafras, an earth beneath
my hooved feet elastic with its mosses, I walk out
to the human clearing, late winter, under a surplus of stars.
Gently, neighbor-like, my animal ear upheld against
the wigwam, the stripped bark sides of it like the surface
of a rumored planet, discernible at last in the late winter
sky that appears, as noted, invested with more stars
than necessary, although necessity would seem to have
no place in the matter, and it must be I who has imported it.
In the firelight the colonist feeds the dying sachem
fruit preserves with a blunt English knife, nursing him back
to health, and it's my task to determine, through
the tension of the wigwam, whether he performs this
kindness out of love, strategy, or else some mixture of
the two, and if this last, I am asked to determine whether
the two feelings stay distinct in the mixture, or if
they fuse, and if the latter, what known apparatus might
best take the measure, or what new one might we devise,
and is it love-strategy then, or strategy-love, is one half
always stronger, or is it not like that at all.
When I fly
back to where I'm from, or feel I must be, will I be thought
a failure to the others there, because I am, but only
in the strict sense, having failed to accomplish what I felt
I had been asked to, which was to undertake what
can't in fact be done, not the way we had been made to
think we might be able to. That was our mistake, if we were
more than one. If not, then it was mine. I worry that
I won't be able, in the strict sense, to make the others
see the beauty of it, all of it, which I admit I can only
see in part, even after lifelong travels, and then I think,
this must be what they want, for me to return incapable,
brokener, insisting on the beauty of what can't be
understood, not the way we thought, and they, if more
than one, will welcome me, nodding in time like the holy
entities on a diptych, and if otherwise, I will be there
to becalm myself, and to be the ship I wait for, and the ocean
will be ocean, no matter how I cross it, and late winter
sky will still be sky, until there's no ship left to wait for.
Erin Belieu on Timothy Donnelly
In Ancient Egypt, there lived powerful magicians who could cast something called a binding spell, an enchantment that tangled a person in invisible restraints, bending them to the supplicant's will. A form of sorcery known as sympathetic magic, it is one of the oldest spells known to humankind.
So when I say that I find Timothy Donnelly's poems charming, I mean to describe them with all the authoritative resonance this secondary definition musters. His poems are slyly incantatory, wrapping the reader inside their syntactic complexity. They captivate with the three dimensional quality of their illusions.
They are also charming in the more traditional sense, salutary, welcoming, funny, precise, vulnerable, appealingly neurotic on occasion. They have a flirtatious quality of mind and eye that draws their reader inexorably. Again, I want to qualify that to flirt doesn't mean to make yourself entirely and boringly agreeable. Donnelly's poems are willing to antagonize as necessary, understanding those essential energies opposition brings to a poem. With their intellectual sinuousness, they weave a complete and very particular consciousness around their reader. Donnelly's poems sound like a very specific and especially vivid someone made them.
Donnelly's poems are also not afraid to bang on your door. They're not self conscious about asking for the attention they require. They have a lot of important stuff they need to talk about. But as is the case with the very best raconteurs, when listening to Donnelly's poems, you're likely to forget about the other urgencies calling to you. It seems there's no where else we need to be once we're inside of them. Keeping in mind that poetry is—or should be—another version of magic, it's a great pleasure to be bewitched by such a confident, generous, and singularly-voiced poet.