Old School

On Emily Dickinson

The Soul selects her own Society

The Soul selects her own Society —
Then — shuts the Door —
To her divine Majority —
Present no more —

Unmoved — she notes the Chariots — pausing —
At her low Gate —
Unmoved — an Emperor be kneeling
Upon her Mat —

I've known her — from an ample nation —
Choose One —
Then — close the Valves of her attention —
Like Stone —


This is one of ED's smartest or wisest poems.

Her insight tickles; it also encourages.

Even before I knew I was a poet,

Something was promising me that my choice, not

Only of whom but of what (beauty, art, poetry) to love would be valid; that however

Unclear most things were in my world,

Love would be clear and

Simple. And soulful. (Don't you love the s's in that first line?

Ever notice there are four of them? And how they slow the line up? Then

Look how the next line snaps shut!

Emily reproduces, rhythmically, the careful intentionality of selection and its


Then she brings politics into it, but sideways. Divinely,

"Soul" outvotes the opposition. Majority rules. Soul as majority? How improbable!

How painfully I remember, in childhood—and thereafter—always being in the minority.

Emily perhaps shared that experience. She didn't get mad, she got even.

Rejection can be fun, when your soul does the rejecting.

Of course, it's especially fun to imagine rejecting your social superiors.

Well, it is for me. But did Emily have social superiors?

No—but she did have some pompous men in her life.

Sweet and pretty fantasy to make them collectively kneel.

Open and shut case. And so feminine,

Capitalizing, for one's imagery, on feminine anatomy. Those valves!

I admire and enjoy the way in the

End, they turn impregnable as stone.

This is one of the many reasons I admire and love

You, Emily.

More Old School

On John Keats’s “This living hand”

I was just starting out when I stumbled upon John Keats's last serious gesture in poetry, the final fragment, a terminal point. I felt the blood in his hand, the trauma of what could never be finished, the lure of the partially whole, and it has reminded me ever since that poetry is a bloody art. It's a form of play, true, but the stakes are mortal. Everything is on the line.

Read Article
On George Oppen’s “Of Being Numerous”

I was 23 and self-effacing, my hair in a tight bun, when I read these lines, out of George Oppen's Of Being Numerous. I read them on my hour or so ride on the Q train, when I went to teach Brighton Beach community college students who had failed their basic reading and writing exam. That season, in which one of my students left obscene phrases on torn pieces of paper on my desk, I tried to teach poetry to him and the others and sometimes succeeded.

Read Article